Buying guide

Which mitt for which job?

Two mitts for coaches: one for catching hard returns at close range, one for fielding drills. Compared on material, size and what each is built to take.

A coach running a two-hour session catches more balls than anyone on the field, which is why a mitt is a piece of protective equipment and not a novelty. The choice is between depth of pocket and range of movement.

Are you receiving, or fielding?

If you are stood close taking hard returns over and over — feeding a machine, catching for a keeper — the catcher's mitt is the one: deeper pocket, more palm padding, and leather only, because PU does not survive that volume. If you are moving through fielding drills and scooping balls off the ground, the fielding mitt is lighter, comes in four sizes, and offers a cheaper PU version.

Side by side

 3D Baseball Catchers Mitt
$175.00
3D Baseball Fielding / Catching Mitt
$110.00
MaterialPig-hide leatherPU or leather
Sizes33.5" and 34.5"11.5", 12.5", 13.5", 14.5"
PocketExtra-large, reinforced with additional stitchingExtra-large, reinforced with additional stitching
PaddingReinforced palm

Which one, and who for

Buy it for: General coaching. Four sizes from 11.5" to 14.5", moulded fingers for scooping off the ground, and a PU option at a lower price for lighter use.

Not for: Thousands of hard returns a week. That is what the catcher's mitt exists for, and PU will not last it.

Questions

Do cricket coaches use baseball mitts?

Widely, yes. A mitt lets a coach catch hard returns from a machine or a keeper for hours without bruising, which is why both of these are sold for cricket sessions rather than for baseball.

Is a leather mitt worth the extra over PU?

It depends on volume. Leather takes far more impact and lasts longer under repetitive drill work; PU is fine for occasional use and costs less. The catcher's mitt is leather only for that reason.

How do I choose a mitt size?

Fielding mitts are measured 11.5" to 14.5" — bigger gives a larger catching area and less control. Catcher's mitts are measured differently, at 33.5" and 34.5" around the circumference. Pick the throwing hand, not the catching hand: an RH throw mitt is worn on the left.

Shop mitts & glovesWhich ball for which machine?What to add to a machine.